30 Comments
User's avatar
Liz Callaway's avatar

I’m going to use the “three pitches” constraint today when I force myself to sit down and write my Substack!

David Epstein's avatar

Right into action, I love it;)

Margit Kir-Stimon's avatar

So looking forward to reading the book. It sounds like it's brimming with wonderful ideas to promote our writing and creativity. Can't wait to read it!!

David Epstein's avatar

Thank you Margit! Really looking forward to your thoughts.

Joe Radosevich's avatar

I'm a pastor, and every week I force myself to write 7 versions of my "point of the sermon." I rarely use the first versions. I usually find a breakthrough around the 4th version. Even if I think I've said it perfectly, I force myself to do at least 7.

David Epstein's avatar

Joe, now I'm thinking I need to expand past three! Thanks so much for sharing this. And as a total aside, for chapter six of the new book I read a lot of mid-20th century sermons from prominent preachers, and I was blown away but how interesting and creative some of them were. It made me want to do some kind of project on the rhetorical techniques of great preachers.

Joe Radosevich's avatar

Thanks for the reply! I recommend Range to people regularly, and I'm looking forward to this new one--especially chapter six.

Kathleen Smith's avatar

Love this! I do family therapy and sometimes I ask people to think of 3 ways that relationships might improve. People tend to get stuck in thinking that there's only one way (which usually involves someone else growing up) for things to get better.

David Epstein's avatar

I love it. The "Three Improvements Rule." I'm just going to take this for my own personal use.

Danielle Newnham's avatar

I love that your research with Ed including watching a film with him - lucky!

Elaine Aradillas's avatar

Just pre-ordered! I can't wait to read more about Isabel Allende.

Congrats!

David Epstein's avatar

Elaine! So nice to see you here. Isabel is incredible—such a character. And obviously I needed an excuse to hang with one of the great writers in the world. … And then in one of her books she used the name Epstein just in passing for a family. And I was like: I have peaked.

Delia Lloyd's avatar

When I teach creativity I have the students do an exercise where they have to come up with a bunch of things that are "orange" for 1 minute. Then we do it again. And again. The idea is that you best ideas are never your first ones...I believer there is some evidence base out there to this effect! But I like it as a writing idea too.

David Epstein's avatar

Your students are lucky to have you Delia!

Emily GreenPurpleFireDragon's avatar

I’m reading Iain McGilchrist’s The Master and His Emissary. On how the two halves of the brain do the same things but differently. It’s interesting to think about what might be going on there repeating this exercise.

Delia Lloyd's avatar

that is interesting...

Brittany Mcvicker's avatar

I really love this piece. I’ve never actually read into Pixar. Great read. I’m actually a film producer and always excited to meet more writers and film people on here.

I’ve been sharing thoughts on screenwriting, development, and the reality of getting projects off the ground. Sounds like you’re are building in film, you might find this useful. https://itsbrittanymcvicker.substack.com/p/the-business-of-screenwriting?r=8dfuvt&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

Gregory Keyes's avatar

At Corporate, we had a 3-designs rule. (Somewhere on LinkedIn I wrote about.) Had to come up with three different designs to present in a preliminary design review before committing to a detailed design. It was really hard to get folks to get past their one ultimate design, but it worked (mostly). There’s a Goldilocks zone somewhere between being over constrained and under constrained 🧐

Ian Winter's avatar

Ignore this if you’ve heard it before (as it’s from 18 months ago) but have you heard Bella Freud’s Fashion Neurosis podcast/chat with Nick Cave? He talks about his love of frameworks, guardrails and traditions as essential components of his creativity.

LB - The Happy Underachiever's avatar

Love the video! Another sports anecdote which I tell my hockey player son who sometimes gets all doom and gloom when a "setback" occurs is the Connor Bedard's wrist injury story. Bedard fractured his dominant one at 12 so it forced him to start using his non-dominant hand when stickhandling/shooting at home. This contributed to a pretty unique and successful style of shooting. At 13 yrs old, he was playing with 16 year olds.

Chris Blachut's avatar

This could also be a way to challenge LLM's biases and better tap into and take advantage of their creative powers.

Doug Glanville's avatar

A baseball player reads the title “Three Pitches” and is not sure what to do with it. I didn’t walk. Hopefully, I didn’t strike out.

I certainly find this to be true in doing voiceovers. Warming up. First attempt is usually the worst. Part of it is that I had not committed much to memory until I read it which locks in even more when I voiced it. The first draft is untested and two dimensional whenever I do it.

The sense of time and the drag to an arcade baseball game world of one pitch, one outcome is so tantalizing today. Be first. Swing first. And even in major league baseball, hitters do very well when they swing at the first pitch. Statistically.

But consider one season, I hardly ever swung at the first pitch of the game. I noticed teams were figuring it out so one day the team that traded me, the Chicago Cubs, came to town. I decided way in advance that I was going to jump on the first pitch of our game (Bottom of the 1st). I hit a basehit up the middle and the best part was the annoyed shrug by the Cubs pitcher that he directed at the Cubs dugout. Clearly unhappy with the scouting report. :)

Wishing you well on Three Pitches. When you add a bonus chapter. Feel free to name it the fourth pitch so I could give myself a chance to walk without swinging.

Henny Hiemenz's avatar

After months of vacillating I finally tossed the opening to my book. It was painful, but needed to be done. I wish I’d read this earlier 😀

Emily GreenPurpleFireDragon's avatar

I’m on my, um, 2nd pitch of the video game Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom. The first time was exploratory. Discovering things as they came along, seeing how they worked. But I got stuck using my same evasive solutions over & over, like flying past all the monsters on the paraglider, or using rocket shields to shoot arrows at them in bullet time. This time I decided to see how much of the game I could do without the paraglider. I’ve made so many neat discoveries about all the other tools available in the game. And discovered that I can get through monster fights more easily than I used to think.

Interesting to me is that this attitude is also rubbing off onto real life: if I take away the tools I automatically use first, what else can I do?

Evan Kramer's avatar

Love this idea to overcome sunk cost fallacy and endowment effect (https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/261737). Would be interesting to see if "three pitches" worked to reduce the endowment effect empirically. My chat with Gemini suggests so but is a little mixed (https://gemini.google.com/share/c8d96faf2e70).

Also love trying to reduce the discomfort of feeling/hearing "You started in the wrong place" to incentivize ranging widely.

Insightful as always. Thank you for what you share.